Blurred Line between Federal Immigration Enforcement and Local Police Harms Communities
Five men arrived at a construction equipment company on the outskirts of Green Valley looking for work when a sheriff’s deputy offered the men a ride into town and brought them to a nearby restaurant — where Border Patrol was ready to detain them.
Unaware to the five men, an onsite security guard at the construction equipment company had called the Pima County Sheriff’s Department and U.S. Border Patrol, despite the men not causing any issues. That March 2023 incident report — obtained through a public records request by the ACLU of Arizona — offers a glimpse into how local law enforcement agencies regularly assist federal immigration authorities.
Court Finds Sheriff Nanos Violated Arizona Public Records Law, New Records on Immigration Encounters Obtained – ACLU of Arizona
Court Finds Sheriff Nanos Violated Arizona Public Records Law, New Records on Immigration Encounters Obtained – ACLU of Arizona
Public records, firsthand anonymous interviews with recently deported people, and information from migrant aid organizations indicate unclear boundaries between immigration enforcement and ordinary policing. As the Trump administration expands federal, state, and local authority to enforce immigration laws, key questions emerge: What does that look like in practice? And what are the harms to local communities?
“You could argue that there’s no inherent problem with collaboration between agencies,” said John Mitchell, an immigrants’ rights attorney with the ACLU of Arizona. “But the reality is more complicated when you see how state and local law enforcement are given some level of unchecked power, and how they translate that into their actual enforcement.”
Trump Administration Rapidly Expands Local Police and Federal Immigration Collaboration
During his second term, President Donald Trump rapidly expanded the 287(g) program, which allows local law enforcement agencies to enter into agreements with U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) and assume limited federal immigration enforcement duties.
At the start of 2025, 133 state and local agencies participated in the program. By February 2026, ICE had signed an additional 1,079 agencies to 287(g) agreements, according to the ACLU report “Deputized for Disaster.” One of those newly signed agencies is the Utah County Sheriff’s Office with its Task Force Model, which gives local police the authority to investigate immigration status of anyone they come across, including witnesses and victims of criminal investigations. It could even happen during a traffic stop.
Deputized for Disaster
Deputized for Disaster
Andres, a father from Mexico, moved to Utah to reunite with his daughter. About a year later, in November 2025, a Utah County sheriff’s deputy pulled him over for a traffic infraction, he said. After Andres showed his Mexican identification, the deputy called immigration authorities. He was detained for about 24 days before being deported to Nogales, Sonora, a major border city in Mexico south of Arizona, where he shared his experience with the ACLU of Arizona.
The Task Force Model can lead to racial profiling, according to the ACLU report — which means police often use an individual’s perceived race, ethnicity, or national origin to determine whether to investigate the person for legal violations, including those related to immigration status. But racial profiling is not unique to 287(g) agreements. It is a longstanding and troubling practice documented among law enforcement agencies, including those that are not actively participating in the program. And this isn’t only happening in Arizona. As of October, more than 2,500 cities and states nationwide have signed 287(g) agreements.
Local Law Enforcement Operate Without Accountability
In Arizona, the Pima and Santa Cruz County sheriff’s offices have no active 287(g) agreements. Still, incident reports obtained through public records requests show instances of assistance and coordination with federal immigration authorities.
In September 2025, a Santa Cruz County sheriff’s deputy pulled over a driver for a cracked windshield. When the deputy approached the driver’s window, he noticed three men in the backseat.
“I asked [the driver] to tell me what was going on. I added that I already knew what was occurring,” the deputy wrote in the incident report.The driver said he had picked up the men in Nogales, Arizona and was taking them to Phoenix. According to the incident report, the deputy detained the driver in their patrol unit and activated the child locks on the civilian vehicle to prevent the other three men from leaving. Border Patrol agents arrived shortly after and took over.
Mitchell cautioned that incident reports are one-sided accounts written from an officer’s perspective. And in this case, the deputy’s report lacked enough detail to establish suspicion of a crime within the sheriff’s jurisdiction.
“State and local law enforcement officers don’t have the same amount of training and specialized background to distinguish border crimes from immigration violations,” Mitchell said. “And building off of that, you see a lot of oversimplification and bias creep into the actual enforcement practices of state and local police.”
As he sat inside a migrant shelter in Nogales, Sonora, a border city in Mexico, last December, Carlos, a man from Mexico who lived in the United States for four years, recalled the moment of his arrest. He said a sheriff’s deputy in Twin Falls, Idaho pulled him over while on his way to work one morning, saying Carlos had resembled the description of a suspect in an open case. When Carlos handed his Mexican passport, the deputy called ICE and laughed as he handcuffed Carlos. Carlos said he believed that the deputy’s reaction had been primarily based on racial profiling — an example of how racial bias and xenophobia creeps into law enforcement practices and is often not addressed by training or other accountability measures.
As Civilians Exercise Rights, Officers Turn to Brutal Force
Unlawful law enforcement tactics are well documented, which is why Mitchell noted that it’s important for individuals to know how to exercise their constitutional rights.
Immigrants' Rights
Agents of Chaos and Cruelty: How the Trump Administration's National Deportation Policing Force Has Attacked American Communities
Immigrants' Rights
Agents of Chaos and Cruelty: How the Trump Administration's National Deportation Policing Force Has Attacked American Communities
Miguel, a father who was deported to Nogales, Sonora last winter, said an SUV cornered his car as he drove on a highway in Seattle and forced him to pull over. Three men, who didn’t identify themselves, began questioning Miguel about his immigration status. Miguel showed them his Washington driver license, then the men called ICE. Given their lack of uniforms and badges, Miguel questioned whether the men were immigration officers. But he complied out of fear of escalating the situation into a violent encounter.
Mitchell noted: “People have no obligation to follow their lawful commands until they have identified themselves as law enforcement agents. But in practice, that’s not how it works.”
“Law enforcement officers should not be escalating a situation, but that is not at all what we’re seeing now,” Mitchell said. “We are seeing agents using violence and excessive force and other unlawful tactics in order to fulfill the aims of the Trump administration.”
The migrant aid organization, Kino Border Initiative (KBI), shared the story of Jairo, a lawful permanent resident who lived in Arizona for 22 years. After dropping his son at a bus stop, several men approached his vehicle and identified themselves as ICE agents but showed no identification.
Through his window, Jairo repeatedly told them he was a permanent resident. But the men broke into his car, then assaulted and arrested him. When Jairo’s wife tried to intervene, the men beat her too. KBI said she had a miscarriage two days later. Jairo was deported to Mexico.
In another instance last May, ICE agents forcibly entered the Tucson home of Karla Toledo, a DACA recipient who has lived most of her life in the United States. When Toledo demanded a warrant, ICE agents forced their way into her home without showing one.
“Do you exercise your rights, or do you keep yourself insulated from the possibility of a law enforcement agent escalating the situation?” Mitchell said. “That should never be a choice that people have to make.”
ACLU Continues to Track Patterns and Monitor New Practices
These documented encounters with law enforcement authorities reveal patterns about how an agency operates, Mitchell said. Additionally, they help infer how an agency might enforce new laws when given expanded authority.
For example, the ACLU of Arizona continues to monitor the implementation of Arizona’s Proposition 314, Section 5 — which grants local police authority to enforce violations of illegal entry from a foreign country.
Know Your Rights under Proposition 314 – ACLU of Arizona
Know Your Rights under Proposition 314 – ACLU of Arizona
“It opens up a number of concerning possibilities,” Mitchell said. “We don’t know how local law enforcement is being trained to investigate and enforce this law. We also don’t know how state courts might treat these new types of charges.”
One thing remains clear and urgent: As immigration enforcement expands, Mitchell said, local and state agencies need clear policies governing how officers and agents are expected to respond.
“Law enforcement agencies at every level, from rural county sheriff’s departments to ICE, routinely violate people’s rights under the guise of immigration enforcement,” Mitchell said. “Congress, states, and local governments must do better to support communities by creating tools for meaningful accountability in the face of these abuses.”